Canadian privacy & access decisions

The complainant alleged that the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) improperly withheld information under paragraph 16(1)(a) of the Access to Information Act. The requested information pertained to a complaint investigated by the RCMP. The OIC's investigation determined that the withheld information was obtained by the RCMP, an investigative body specified in the regulations, during a lawful investigation related to the detection, prevention, or suppression of crime. Furthermore, the information was created less than twenty years before the request. The OIC also found that the RCMP reasonably exercised its discretion by considering relevant factors for and against disclosure, including the purpose of the Act and the private interests of other individuals. Consequently, the OIC concluded that the information met the requirements for exemption under paragraph 16(1)(a) and that the institution's decision to withhold it was appropriate.

• Whether the information was obtained or prepared by an investigative body listed in Schedule I of the Access to Information Regulations
• Whether the information was obtained or prepared during a lawful investigation within the authority of the investigative body
• Whether the investigation concerned the detection, prevention, or suppression of crime, enforcement of law, or threats to security of Canada
• Whether the information was created less than 20 years before the access request
• Whether the institution reasonably exercised its discretion to decide whether to release the information under s.16(1)(a)