Canadian Privacy Decisions

The complainant requested information related to applications and Minimum Safe Manning (MSM) Documents for the passenger ship Queen of Cumberland. Transport Canada withheld information under subsections 19(1) (personal information) and 20(1)(b) (confidential third-party information). The complainant later withdrew the section 19(1) aspect of the complaint. The Information Commissioner found that Transport Canada failed to demonstrate that the withheld information met the requirements of paragraph 20(1)(b), ordering the disclosure of all information previously withheld under that provision.

• Whether the withheld information met the criteria for paragraph 20(1)(b) of the ATIA, specifically concerning its technical nature, confidentiality, whether it was supplied by a third party, and if it was consistently treated as confidential by the third party.
• Whether the information was publicly available or observable by passengers, impacting the confidentiality claim.
• Whether the MSI's handwritten notes and the completed MSMDs constituted information supplied by a third party.
• The third party's (BC Ferries) lack of position on the disclosure of the information.