Canadian Privacy Decisions

The complainant alleged that Transport Canada improperly withheld information related to rail workplace fatality investigation reports. The request was for copies of all such reports completed since January 2000. The Information Commissioner found that Transport Canada failed to demonstrate that the exemptions for personal information (s.19) and third-party commercial/financial/technical information (s.20) were properly applied in all instances. Specifically, Transport Canada did not reasonably exercise its discretion regarding publicly available personal information and failed to justify withholding certain third-party information.

• Proper application of the personal information exemption (s.19 ATIA)
• Proper application of the third-party commercial, financial, or technical information exemption (s.20(1)(b) ATIA)
• Proper application of the third-party financial impact or competitive harm exemption (s.20(1)(c) ATIA)
• Reasonable exercise of discretion by the institution

The complainant alleged that Health Canada improperly withheld information related to campfires and air quality, citing exemptions for personal information and financial impact on third parties. Health Canada initially withheld names and short texts about third parties under the financial impact exemption. However, the third parties did not provide evidence of material financial harm, and one explicitly stated disclosure would not cause harm. The Information Commissioner found the complaint well-founded, ordering Health Canada to disclose the withheld information.

• Whether information withheld under paragraph 20(1)(c) met the requirements of the exemption.
• Whether third parties demonstrated a material financial impact or harm to their competitive position.
• Whether disclosure was in the public interest and outweighed potential harm.

The complainant alleged that Transport Canada improperly withheld information related to an investigation into an accidental death. The request was for the final investigation report. Transport Canada withheld information claiming exemptions for law enforcement, personal information, and confidential third-party commercial information. The Information Commissioner found that the institution and the third party failed to demonstrate that the exemptions applied to certain information, ordering disclosure of the incident number and other non-exempt records. Transport Canada agreed to comply with the order.

• Applicability of paragraph 16(1)(c) (law enforcement and conduct of investigations)
• Applicability of subsection 19(1) (personal information)
• Applicability of paragraph 20(1)(b) (confidential third-party commercial information)
• Burden of proof on the institution and third party to justify exemptions