Canadian privacy & access decisions

The complainant alleged that Library and Archives Canada (LAC) improperly withheld information under subsections 15(1) (national security) and 19(1) (personal information) of the Access to Information Act. The request sought information related to "Active Measures – The Soviet Bloc Practice of Deception, Disruption and Defamation." Initially, LAC withheld the entire 33-page record but later dropped its reliance on subsection 19(1) and released some information. The Information Commissioner found that LAC failed to demonstrate that the remaining withheld information met the requirements of subsection 15(1), noting the extensive public domain information on the topic. Despite the Commissioner's recommendation to disclose all remaining information, LAC refused to implement it. Consequently, the complaint was found to be well founded.

• Whether s.15(1) national security exemption was properly applied
• Whether disclosure could reasonably be expected to harm national security
• Whether the institution provided sufficient justification for the s.15(1) claim
• Whether the information was already in the public domain
• Whether s.19(1) personal information exemption was properly applied