Canadian privacy & access decisions

Two Dell customers complained to the OPC after receiving "tech support scam" calls where fraudsters possessed their personal Dell product information, alleging insufficient security safeguards and inadequate complaint handling by Dell. The OPC's investigation revealed that two employees of Dell's service provider in India had sold customer data lists in June and November 2017, affecting at least 7,883 Canadians. The OPC found Dell responsible for the personal information, concluding that its safeguards related to access controls, logging, monitoring, and technical measures were insufficient given the data's sensitivity and the high-risk environment. Dell also failed to adequately investigate the June 2017 breach and respond to customer complaints. Following the OPC's recommendations, Dell implemented numerous enhancements, including changing service providers, improving security protocols, and revising complaint handling procedures. Consequently, the OPC deemed the matter well-founded and resolved.

• Whether Dell adequately safeguarded personal information under its control while using a service provider (PIPEDA Principle 4.1.3 and 4.7).
• Whether the personal information transferred to the service provider was sensitive enough to require a high degree of protection.
• Whether Dell's access controls were sufficient to protect customer information.
• Whether Dell's logging and monitoring practices were adequate to detect anomalous employee requests for customer information.
• Whether Dell's technical measures, such as USB drive restrictions, were sufficient.
• Whether Dell adequately investigated the circumstances and scope of the June 2017 breach.
• Whether Dell adequately responded to customer complaints about potential privacy breaches (PIPEDA Principle 4.10.4).
• Whether Dell remained responsible for personal information transferred to a third party for processing.