Department of Justice Canada (Re), 2026 OIC 39

The complainant alleged that the Department of Justice Canada improperly withheld a "Final report: Mandatory Minimum Penalties. Recommendations to the Minister of Justice and Attorney General of Canada. Expert Panel on Sentencing Reform" under sections 14 and 21(1)(a) of the Access to Information Act. The Department argued that disclosure would harm federal-provincial affairs and that the report constituted advice or recommendations from internal-like advisors. The Commissioner found no reasonable expectation of harm to federal-provincial affairs, noting the report was six years old, drafted by volunteers, and did not detail active negotiations or provincial positions. Furthermore, the Commissioner determined that the report was prepared by external consultants, not employees or ministerial staff, thus falling under an exception to the advice and recommendations exemption. Consequently, the Commissioner ordered the Department to disclose the records in their entirety, and the Department agreed to comply.