5824-02892 — Privy Council Office

The complainant alleged that the Privy Council Office's (PCO) record-keeping practices for appointment processes did not comply with the Access to Information Act (ATIA), specifically regarding the disposal of interview notes. PCO stated that selection members take notes during interviews to aid deliberations, but these are considered transitory records and are disposed of after the final advice letter to the Minister is prepared, which constitutes the official record. The complainant also suggested PCO's practices might constitute an offense under the ATIA. The investigation found no evidence that records were destroyed with the intent to deny a right of access. Instead, the interview notes were deemed transitory records used in preparing advice letters. The Commissioner concluded that there was no obligation under the ATIA for PCO to retain these notes, nor did their destruction violate the Act. The complaint was therefore not well founded.