5822-04499 — Indigenous Services Canada

The complainant alleged that Indigenous Services Canada (ISC) improperly withheld information related to a 2000 settlement agreement between the Crown and the Squamish Nation, including maps and appendices, under paragraphs 20(1)(c), 20(1)(d), and section 23 of the Access to Information Act. The OIC investigated, seeking representations from both ISC and the Squamish Nation. Neither party provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate a clear and direct connection between the disclosure of specific information and a reasonable expectation of harm under the claimed exemptions. The Commissioner found that much of the information was already in the public domain and that the arguments for financial impact, interference with negotiations, or the application of solicitor-client/litigation privilege were speculative or unfounded. Consequently, the Commissioner ordered ISC to disclose the records in their entirety. ISC, however, notified the Commissioner that it would not implement the order, citing potential negative impacts on its relationship with the Squamish Nation and other Indigenous Peoples.