Library and Archives Canada (Re), 2021 OIC 34

The complainant alleged that Library and Archives Canada (LAC) failed to conduct a reasonable search for an index containing information about all military personnel who served in World War II. The investigation revealed that LAC does not possess such a comprehensive index. While LAC holds paper-based World War II personnel records, these also include personnel from other conflicts and do not contain information on reservists. Furthermore, these records have not been digitized or used to create an electronic database from which a complete list could be generated. Although LAC can respond to requests for specific individuals, the Commissioner found that the institution does not have the requested index. Therefore, the Commissioner concluded that LAC's search was reasonable given the non-existence of the requested record.